Many Obamacare Consumers Pay More Than They Can Afford For Benefits They Won’t Use
On average, a healthy 30-year old will pay almost twice as much for an Obamacare bronze plan as he or she will for a short term health insurance plan.1 One factor in the high price of Obamacare is that even entry-level bronze plans must cover ten specific health benefits, from office visits to prenatal care to psychology services. While extensive coverage makes sense for those who will use these services, many consumers are paying high premiums for Obamacare plans that include benefits they neither need nor can afford. For these consumers, a short term health insurance plan can be a smart alternative.
Under the Affordable Care Act, Obamacare marketplace plans must cover what are deemed ten essential health benefits. They include:
These ten essential benefits come at price. The average premium for a 30-year old purchasing a bronze level plan is $243.40 a month.2 For the individual seeking treatment for substance abuse, the expectant mother, or the athlete in need of physical therapy, Obamacare will provide coverage. Similarly, for someone who engages in high-risk activities like rodeo riding or contact sports, where injuries may require extensive therapy, an Obamacare plan may be the expensive but right choice.
But what about the individual who is in good health and doesn’t pursue risky sports or have expensive pre-existing conditions ? These consumers may not always need or desire prenatal, pediatric, mental health, or substance abuse care and an Obamacare plan represents an expensive premium with many insurance benefits that will go unused.
Short Term health insurance streamlines benefits, focusing on key services—doctor/specialist visits, emergency room services, hospital treatment, and lab tests. Note that these services are among the same benefits required by Obamacare. In addition, short term health plans often offer discount cards for prescriptions and dental care. And they maintain deductibles and out-of pocket caps that are within the same range as an Obamacare bronze plan, but for a significantly lower premium. The average monthly premium for a 30-year old male purchasing a short term health plan is $109.71, and $138.04 for a 30-year old female, a savings of 49 percent over a bronze plan.3
Because short term health insurance is not a marketplace plan, an individual may be subject to the Obamacare tax penalty. However, there are a number of exceptions to the tax that consumers can explore and, even with the tax, short term health can be less expensive than Obamacare.
For those in generally good health, the Obamacare benefits comes at a high price, one many cannot afford. For these consumers, a short term health plan can provide the health benefits they need at a price they can afford.
- Premium Data for 2016 Shows that Term Health Insurance Costs 49 Percent Less than Obamacare for Younger Enrollees, AgileHealthInsurance Report, November 19, 2015. https://www.agilehealthinsurance.com/health-insurance-learning-center/term-insurance-costs-less-for-younger-enrollees